Buffalo Phil's Pizza & Grille Menu

Welcome to Buffalo Phil's Pizza & Grille, where fun meets flavor in Wisconsin Dells! This vibrant eatery offers a delightful menu that features an array of American classics, notably their gigantic pizzas and mouthwatering appetizers like cheese curds served with chunky marinara. The restaurant's unique ambiance is enhanced by LEGO displays and a whimsical train delivering food right to your table, creating a memorable dining experience for families and groups alike.

  • Family-Friendly Atmosphere: Enjoy a casual yet classy setting, ideal for kids with interactive activities and special frozen drinks like Frogger Lime slushies.
  • Full Bar Options: Pair your meal with an extensive selection of frozen margaritas or a glass of red wine.
  • Accessible & Convenient: With options for takeout, delivery, and on-site parking, Buffalo Phil's makes meals easy and enjoyable.

So gather your loved ones and dive into a fun dining adventure that satisfies every palate!

Appetizers

Macho Nachos

Tortilla chips topped with melted nacho cheese, diced tomatoes, green onions, and sliced black olives. Your choice of taco meat, pulled pork, or pulled chicken. Served with salsa.

$15.99

Onion Rings

Crispy & deep-fried.

$10.99

Mexi-Chips & Salsa

Tortilla chips served with salsa.

$8.99

Chicken Wings

8 bone-in chicken wings tossed in your choice of Smooth & Sassy BBQ, Smokey Bacon BBQ, Spicy Wing Sauce, or naked.

$16.99

Artichoke Spinach Dip

Served warm with chips and veggie sticks.

$12.99

Loaded Mini Tacos

Chicken-filled mini tacos, fried crispy, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, green onions, and salsa ranch sauce.

$13.99

Phil's Garlic Bread

5 slices of savory buttered garlic bread. Served with a side of marinara.

$8.99

Santa Fe Quesadilla

A flour tortilla filled with your Monterey jack, cheddar cheese, and your choice of pulled rotisserie chicken or pork. Served with a side of sour cream, lettuce & salsa.

$13.99

Boneless Wings

12oz. of boneless wing bites. Served naked.

$14.99

Cheese Curds

1/2 pound of breaded & fried white cheese curds. Served with ranch or marinara.

$13.99

Soft Pretzel Sticks

4 Traditional style pretzel sticks baked crispy. Served with nacho cheese sauce.

$13.99

Grilled Shrimp Bruschetta

Marinated shrimp topped with freshly made bruschetta on grilled sourdough bread.

$13.99

Deep-Fried Pickle Chips

Sliced pickles tossed with bread crumb blend, fried to perfection and served with chipotle aioli.

$11.99

Texas Chicken Salad

Mixed greens drizzled with salsa ranch dressing then covered with sweet corn black bean salsa, roasted red peppers, monterey jack & cheddar. Topped with pulled rotisserie chicken & fried tortilla straws.

$16.99

Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce with parmesan, croutons and Caesar dressing.

$13.99

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Mixed greens drizzled with ranch dressing topped with tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, celery & crumbled blue cheese. Covered with a sliced, fried chicken breast drizzled in Spicy Wing Sauce.

$16.99

House Salad

Mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots & onions with your choice of dressing.

$5.99

Soup of the Day

Ask your server about the soup of the day.

$5.99

Soup & Salads

Burgers, Sandwiches & Wraps

Buffalo Burger

A third-pound buffalo burger topped with pulled pork, and cheddar & finished with Smooth & Sassy BBQ Sauce.

$17.25

Alamo Burger

A classic hand pattied burger.

$15.99

Big Cowboy Burger

2 hand pattied burgers topped with bacon, choice of cheese & chipotle mayo.

$18.25

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Our slow-cooked, pulled pork with your choice of BBQ sauce.

$15.99

Pulled Chicken Sandwich

Pulled rotisserie chicken with your choice of BBQ sauce.

$15.99

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Fried chicken breast tossed in Spicy Wing Sauce topped with bacon, lettuce, tomato, provolone & blue cheese dressing on a toasted ciabatta.

$17.25

Plain Fried Chicken Sandwich

Crispy fried chicken breast with lettuce, tomato & onion.

$14.25

"The Duke" Sandwich

Sliced beef brisket & pulled pork topped with pepperjack & cheddar, onion rings, jalapeños & Smokey Bacon BBQ Sauce.

$18.25

Cheesesteak Sandwich

Shaved beef on a French roll with grilled onions, peppers & mushrooms, horseradish mayo & Swiss.

$17.25

Turkey Panini

Smoked turkey breast, bacon, tomato, provolone & roasted red pepper mayo on ciabatta. Served with chips & salsa.

$15.25

BLT

Bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo on toasted sourdough. Served with chips & salsa.

$14.99

Fried Chicken Wrap

Fried & sliced chicken with Spicy Wing Sauce & ranch dressing with bacon, lettuce, monterey jack & cheddar. Served with chips & salsa.

$17.25

Southwestern Chicken Wrap

Pulled chicken, grilled onions & peppers, lettuce, salsa ranch dressing, monterey jack & cheddar cheese all in a wrap. Served with chips & salsa.

$17.25

Chicken Alfredo

Chicken, broccoli & classic alfredo sauce. Topped with a parmesan cheese blend.

$19.99

Vegetable Alfredo

Broccoli, red & green peppers, onions and sauteed mushrooms with alfredo sauce.

$19.99

Chicken Parmesan

Marinara sauce, red & green peppers, onions, mozzarella & parmesan topped with a fried chicken breast and even more cheese!

$19.99

Creamy Chipotle Vegetable Pasta

Broccoli, red & green peppers, onions and sauteed mushrooms with a mild chipotle cream sauce. Topped with sour cream and chives.

$19.99

Pasta

Entrees

Half Rotisserie Chicken Meal

A half of our slow-roasted famous rotisserie chicken.

$18.99

Whole Rotisserie Chicken Meal

This whole rotisserie chicken meal serves 2 hungry adults! No fights here you also get your choice of 4 sides.

$28.99

Beef Brisket

Cooked for 14 hours. Thick homestyle sliced.

$22.99

Creole Style Jambalaya

Shrimp, andouille, and chicken cooked in a blend of peppers, onions, celery, tomatoes and rice. Topped with sour cream. Excludes additional sides.

$22.99

Fat Man's BBQ

A true feast! Are you up for the challenge? Choose 2: a half of our rotisserie chicken, pulled pork, or beef brisket.

$29.99

Pulled Pork

Our pork is slow-cooked, smoked & pulled. Topped with your choice of BBQ sauce.

$17.99

New York Strip

12oz. strip grilled to your liking.

$29.99

Roasted Salmon

Oven-roasted Norwegian salmon.

$24.99

Friday Fish Fry

Delicious golden fried Cod served with fries and coleslaw.

$17.99

Large 16

$17.99

Small 12

$12.99

Personal

$8.99

Pizzas

Specialty Pizzas

Supreme

Classic pie with pepperoni, onions, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers & mozzarella.

The Sour Pig

Loaded with diced Canadian bacon and sauerkraut. "A Midwest Delight!"

Taco

Taco meat covered with melted cheddar & mozzarella then topped with shredded lettuce, tomatoes & taco chips

The Spicy BBQ Brisket

Made with our Smooth & Sassy BBQ sauce, our signature smoked brisket, caramelized onions, freshly sliced jalapenos, and finished with our homemade chipotle sauce.

Phil's Cheesesteak

Alfredo sauce, provolone & mozzarella cheese topped with shaved beef, onions, red & green peppers.

Vegetarian

Vegetable combo of green peppers, red peppers, broccoli, tomatoes, onions, mushrooms, black olives & mozzarella.

Meat-Lovers

Pepperoni, bacon, Italian sausage, and diced Canadian bacon. "For those who love meat!"

Mac & Cheese

Thick & creamy macaroni & cheese.

$7.99

Grilled Cheese

American cheese melted between two slices of Texas toast.

$7.99

Quarter Chicken

A quarter of our famous rotisserie chicken.

$7.99

Personal Pizza

Personal pizza topped with cheese. Pizza does not come with fries or broccoli.

$8.99

Mini Corn Dogs

6 breaded & fried mini corn dogs.

$7.99

Buckaroo Burger

A smaller beef burger perfect for lil' buckaroo hands.

$7.99

Chicken Strips

3 breaded chicken strips.

$8.99

Kids' Menu-All Lil' Buckaroo Meals can be delivered by train.

Desserts

Fried Ice Cream

Vanilla ice cream rolled in cinnamon sugar, fried & topped with caramel, chocolate & brownie chunks.

$10.99

Sassy Cow Ice Cream

Ice Cream Flavors: Birthday Cake, Cappuccino Crunch, Mint Chip, Purple Cow, Salted Caramel, Vanilla & Triple Chocolate. Ask your server about our Flavor of the Month!

$4.99

Muddy Worm Pie

The chocolate lovers' dream! Chocolate ice cream topped with crushed Oreo cookies and whip cream with gummy worms.

$7.99

OK Corral Cheesecake

A classic & creamy cheesecake topped with your choice of strawberry, caramel or chocolate plus whipped cream.

$11.99

Root Beer Float

Root Beer & vanilla ice cream served in a frosty mug.

$6.99

Tiramisu

Lady fingers layered with mascarpone cheese, espresso and shaved chocolate.

$9.99

Train Wreck

One loaded dessert to share with the family. Chocolate and vanilla ice cream surrounded by chocolate chip cookie pieces, brownie chunks, gummy bears, Oreo cookie crumbles, and whipped cream.

$15.99

Mini Churros

A spin on a traditional Spanish dessert with vanilla ice cream drizzled with chocolate.

$11.99

Pepsi

Free Refills

$3.29

Pepsi Zero

Free Refills

$3.29

Wild Cherry Pepsi

Free Refills

$3.29

Tropicana Lemonade

Free Refills

$2.99

Starry Lemon-Lime

Free Refills

$3.29

Starry Zero

Free Refills

$3.29

Unsweetened Lipton Iced Tea

Free Refills

$3.29

Mug Root Beer

Free Refills

$3.29

Mountain Dew

Free Refills

$3.29

Diet Mountain Dew

Free Refills

$3.29

Coffee

Free Refills

$3.29

Cranberry Juice

Free Refills

$3.29

Apple Juice

Free Refills

$3.29

Cappuccino

$3.29

Hot Chocolate

$3.29

Hot Cider

$3.29

Hot Tea

$3.29

White or Chocolate Milk

$3.29

Beverages

Must-Have for the Kids

Baby Shark

Blue raspberry flavored soda with gummy sharks & worms. Includes souvenir fishbowl with a light-up ice cube you can keep!

$8.99

Baby Unicorn

Cotton candy flavored soda with gummy unicorns & a rainbow. Includes souvenir fishbowl with a light-up ice cube you can keep!

$8.99

Little Frogger

Lime flavored slushie with frog gummies. Includes souvenir fishbowl with a light-up ice cube you can keep!

$9.99

Snowball

White cherry flavored slushie with gummy bears. Includes souvenir fishbowl with a light-up ice cube you can keep!

$9.99

Frozen Drinks for the Kids

Tap Beer

Modelo

Honey Ale

Founders All Day IPA

New Glarus Spotted Cow

Miller Lite

Busch Light

Stella Artois

Blue Moon

Budweiser

$6.00

Bud Light

$6.00

Corona

$6.00

Coors Light

$6.00

Michelob Ultra

$6.00

Heineken

$6.00

Non-Alcoholic Buckler

$6.00

Lakefront's Gluten Free New Grist

Cans

$6.00

White Claw (Flavors Vary)

Cans

$6.00

Bottled Beer

Specialty Drinks

Lone Star Lemonade

A southern staple. Tito's Vodka, Blue Curacao & lemonade; garnished with a lemon slice & a cherry.

$9.50

Buffal-Old Fashioned

Cherry Herring liqueur muddled with orange & cherry, Downtown Toodeloo Rock & Rye Whiskey, topped off with Starry soda & bitters.

$9.50

Wisco Mule

Fieldnotes Vodka, Downtown Toodeloo Rock & Rye Whiskey, lime & ginger beer with a splash of bitters.

$9.50

Skyy Walker

Skyy Cherry Vodka, Melon liqueur, lime juice & Starry soda. Comes with a lighted ice cube.

$10.50

Frozen Flavors

Strawberry, Blackberry, Mango, Peach, Cucumber, Raspberry, Blue Raspberry, Watermelon, Huckleberry, Cranberry, Granny Smith Apple, Blood Orange, Dragon Fruit.

$12.50

Classic Lime

$10.50

Margarita Madness

On the Rocks

Blackberry Margarita

Milagro Silver, Giffard Blackberry Liqueur, Triple Sec & Margarita Mix.

$10.50

Sharkarita

Milagro Silver, Blue Curacao, Triple Sec & Margarita Mix with a splash of Grapefruit. Garnished with an umbrella and gummy sharks.

$13.50

Buffalo Phil's Classic Lime Margarita

On the rocks.

$9.50

Stiff Brick Margarita

Double shot of Milagro Silver, a splash of Giffard Raspberry Liqueur, Triple Sec & Margarita Mix. Garnished with gummy bricks.

$13.50

Chardonnay

Salmon Creek

$8.00

Pinot Grigio

Salmon Creek

$8.00

White Zinfandel

Salmon Creek

$8.00

Moscato

$8.00

Kendall Jackson Chardonnay

$9.00

Relax Riesling

$9.00

Wollersheim Prairie Fumé

$8.00

White Wines

Red Wines

Cabernet Sauvignon

Salmon Creek

$8.00

Merlot

Salmon Creek

$8.00

Pinot Noir

Salmon Creek

$8.00

M&R Asti Split

$9.00

Sparkling Wine